|
Urgent! upload question/mistake/clarification
Link |
by death-blade88
on 2006-01-06 11:05:36 (edited 2006-01-06 13:11:34)
|
|
Too any1 who reads this, Recently their were a few requests for Final Fantasy 7 Advent Children songs. Out of those few requests, i happen to have one called "One Winged Angel - Nobuo Uematsu." So since it was a request, i uploaded it. Then the next day i saw that my upload points wen down -9 and i was like "Impossible"?!?!? So i clarified if it was an actual request, then that request was gone. Now i check the Dl. page, it was not added. I'd like to knoe... 1-why was the request remove? 2-why did i lose points for doing the rite thing(To upload a requested song)? 3-Why did i lose an odd # of points...9??? 4-And lastly, was this a mistake of some sort? |
|
Re: Urgent! upload question/mistake/clarification
Link |
by night_link
on 2006-01-06 13:00:08 (edited 2006-01-06 13:01:16)
|
| First of all, Final Fantasy 7 is a game. Shinji's Game Music was gone a long time ago. So no game songs here! That's probably the first mistake. |
|
Re: Urgent! upload question/mistake/clarification
Link |
by
on 2006-01-06 13:22:18 (edited 2006-01-06 13:22:33)
|
|
On the upload page it clearly states: Please, do not upload any files that violate the Request Rules. The person who made the request broke the rules. It sucks that they did that, even though I have measures in place to avoid such violations. In any case, your upload was a waste of your time, my time, and the server's bandwidth. I understand that this was unintentional, so I did not ban you or yell at you or anything like that. In fact, I created "upload points" in order to give feedback as to wether or not your upload was appreciated and useful. 
|
|
Re: Urgent! upload question/mistake/clarification
Link |
by death-blade88
on 2006-01-06 13:29:09
|
| Oic tyvm 4 ur reply, i am sry for bothering u |
|
Re: Urgent! upload question/mistake/clarification
Link |
by
on 2006-01-06 15:58:54 |
|
Out of curiosity, why was the song request for "Last Order" from FF7 Last Order taken off the request list? I mean, it's debateable, even if it's in a anime-ish style, whether a CG movie (Advent Children) based off of a game (FFVII) is an anime. But FFVII Last Order was essentially a one episode OVA (and in case anyone hasn't seen it, it is in fact undeniably anime as regards to style of animation; thus the argument made against FFVII Advent Children is null). As a side note, I wouldn't assume that the person who made the requests was ignoring the rules. It could be an honest mistake; Final Fantasy is considered anime by many circles, and since Advent Children is a movie, it doesn't quite fall under the "game" clause. Technically it comes down to a debate over wheather something done in CG and not then made to look as if it were drawn by hand is an anime. Of course, I could be wrong, but I think this whole issue is caused by a misunderstanding on what counts as anime, rather than because of someone not knowing and/or heeding the rules.
Sore wa... himitsu.
|
|
Re: Urgent! upload question/mistake/clarification
Link |
by
on 2006-01-06 16:28:07 |
|
Ulto Leif, the short answer is that I define the word "anime" on this website. "Anime" is not an objective set, it is subjective. I agree that "Last Order" was anime. That I removed requests for it, I apologize. I admit I did not pay close attention to some of the requests I removed lately. I was only responding to several forum posts.
|