|
For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
|
Yesterday i was reading a sunday newspaper when i saw the article about orange and lemons. It is said that they ripped off the song "pinoy ako" (the theme song of pinoy big brother) from a foreign group called THE CARE. It is claimed that they copied the rythm of THE CARE's song "the chandeliers". The group denied the accusations of the music writer who knew that they really copied the said song. For me, i don't know how to react to his issue but let's just hope that THE TRUTH WILL SET US FREE... :)
"There are no compacts between lions and men, and wolves and lambs have no concord"
|
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
Link |
by
 GeicoGecko
on 2005-10-16 20:26:34 |
|
Rip-offs are common in the Pop culture, but copying the "rythm"? you say? the rhythm: 1. The pattern of musical movement through time. 2. A specific kind of such a pattern, formed by a series of notes differing in duration and stress: a waltz rhythm. 3. A group of instruments supplying the rhythm in a band. 4. A specific kind of metrical pattern or flow You can't really ripoff someone else's rhythem, because it's like saying A: "OMG! you wrote your music in 4/4 meter YOU BASTARD YOU COPIED ME!!" B: "NO! I WROTE MINE FIRST! YOU COPIED ME!" Yeah? So are you sure you don't mean, the melody? 
I'll eat you. |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
|
Personally, i haven't heard of the song "the chandeliers" by THE CARE. So i can't really decide if it's really the melody they copied. The music writer, the one who said that they really copied it said that she has evidence that will make her statement credible. Some of her evidence are: 1.She has the e-mails of one of the members of "orange and lemons" . Maybe you are wondering "how did she get those e-mails, well she said that they have the same e-mail group w/one of the members. In the e-mail, the member said that "....we didnt have to ask permission to the band(THE CARE),actually they should thank us because they will be famous because we use their material..." 2.She has both copies of the song and she can tell where did the copying started.
"There are no compacts between lions and men, and wolves and lambs have no concord"
|
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
|
but i still have my doubts because they songs are great and they revive the new wave style of mood... still i can't decide...
"There are no compacts between lions and men, and wolves and lambs have no concord"
|
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
Link |
by
on 2005-10-16 23:27:50 |
|
you know, most of the times, artists tend to compose their lyrics on previous songs that they've heard. it might be accidental that they have based the beat of "Pinoy Ako" to The Care's "The Chandeliers." it doesn't mean that they DID inentionally copy it. but whatever it is, it still's good. *blip*  *blip* |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
|
Well yeah it is good,but the problem is the intellectual rights of the song. For example,i'm about to create a song and i'm ging to use the rythm of an another song, then i ask first the permission to use it. But in this situation, they didn't get the permission. I think there is a big chance that they will be acquited of the charges...
"There are no compacts between lions and men, and wolves and lambs have no concord"
|
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
|
about dun sa kapangalan, ok lang naman un e... It's the music that counts... Parang full metal alchemist & full metal panic... Something like that... :)
"There are no compacts between lions and men, and wolves and lambs have no concord"
|
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
Link |
by
on 2005-10-16 23:39:50 |
|
yung oranges and lemons, female ang vocals. kala ko nga sila eh. mas maganda naman kung sa adaption lang, parokya na ako. (meron ba kayong chopsuey: wala na po!). toxicity+chopsuey=ordertaker *blip* *blip* |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
Link |
by
on 2005-10-16 23:47:22 |
|
oi sakura. wala lang. *blip* *blip* |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
|
for now i'm just going to find that stupid song and decide. For once and for all... :)
"There are no compacts between lions and men, and wolves and lambs have no concord"
|
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
| Ponkan |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
|
Orange and lemons pero mas masarap ang aple
smile smile...
|
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
| ~Sakura~ naghahanap ka ng away? |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
| oi! walang away.. mababan kau! |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
Link |
by xenphRAGEum
on 2005-10-20 01:13:56
|
|
hmmm.... flame war? mmm... that tastes delicious.
______________________
Nasci Misrum, Vivere Poena, Angustia mori It is a misery to be born, A pain to live, and a trouble to Die. |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
| ikaw nagsasabi ng ulol, ako pa ngayon may gusto ng away? |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
|
oh cge na cge na.. tama na yan. senseless nmn ung pagaawayan eh dba? kaya wag na kau mag flame war jan.. marereport p sa admin yan.. jester, nagtatanong si ~sakura~ ng maaus ah. wala nmn gaguhan dito.. kao nmn ~sakura~, baka matulad ka pa kay Lucian nian.. pati ikaw jester. tama na yan. |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
| pero sana wala ring ululan. |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
Link |
by xenphRAGEum
on 2005-10-20 21:35:28
|
|
c'mon boys and girls... Mag hunustili kau. Easy lang. Tama na ang bangayan.
______________________
Nasci Misrum, Vivere Poena, Angustia mori It is a misery to be born, A pain to live, and a trouble to Die. |
|
Re: For the Filipinos: Orange and Lemons rip off!!!??
|
I aint filipino but I am interested. So tell me in english what you think, someone who has heard both songs plz. I havent heard many oranges and lemos songs but I liked them, mainly those from Azumanga Daioh..  Jomunga eats your avatars. |
