|
I need assitance in a fallacy determination
Link |
by
 
on 2007-10-29 19:48:00 |
|
Is this a good form? If all As get B and Some As are Cs Therefore Some Cs get B. I try to draw a Venn diagram to see if there's a fallacy problem but I don't see any. But I keep getting this feeling it's a fallacy... Anybody knows?  |
|
Re: I need assitance in a fallacy determination
Link |
by
on 2007-10-29 20:12:33 (edited 2007-10-29 20:13:29)
|
|
This is a valid conclusion. It helps to substitute the following analogy: 1. If all Students get Grades and 2. Some Students are Girls 3. Therefore some Girls get Grades Also, some girls, those who aren't students, don't get grades! 
|