Back | Reverse |

obviously a waste of time so...
Link | by DannusMax on 2007-07-28 11:26:37
well, since my other post was deleted and obviously a waste of time for me to type it, ill just say it here. In order for something to become stable in needs to take in things. Creating a dense matter such as earth. The weaker the black hole the smaller matter needed to fill it up. Such as earth the stronger the the black hole more mass is needed such as the sun. It is said that light bends when moving by gravity. I also heard that light is pulled into black holes. So there are similarites. When i grow up ill prove this to be right. I dont give a crap who tries to stop me.

Re: obviously a waste of time so...
Link | by gendou on 2007-07-28 11:53:45
Logical Fallacies:

1. In order for something to become stable, it needs to take in things.
This is false. A system could be observed as stable without any net gain or loss of energy. The universe is the most obvious example, as energy is neither created nor destroyed. Earth's ecosystem is stable on the order of millions of years, but changes, and requires input of energy. Life is not a good analogy for the universe as a whole. The laws of nature give rise to life but the tendencies of living creatures to require an energy source does NOT apply to the universe its self.

2. Dense matter is made of atoms. All atoms in the universe are produced by fusion in stars. Atoms have an atomic number corresponding to the number of protons. Denser atoms (take lead, for example) are only produced under conditions more extreme than that of our sun, i.e., by larger hotter stars. The Earth is a large clump of atoms that are stuck together by gravity.

3. You cannot fill a black hole. A black hole is NOT A HOLE in the classical sense. A black hole simply defines a region of space inside which the curvature of said space is infinite. This is to say, the inward pull of gravity is strong enough such that no object, not even light, can escape. Any form of energy, including mater, that falls into the black hole adds to the black hole's energy, therefore mass, and therefore radius. It also contributes any angular momentum it has; black holes can be squished oval shapes instead of circles if they have non-zero angular momentum. No other properties (shape, color, atomic composition, for example) of the object remain after it passes the event horizon (the "edge" of the black hole. You may consider that a black hole does not fill because all the mater is condensed to one point, far smaller in diameter than the diameter of the even horizon around it.

4. Gravity does NOT BEND LIGHT. Gravity bends space, in the way a bowling balls bends the fabric of a trampoline. Light travels in a "strait" line, that is, it takes the shortest path from point A to point B. If you roll a golf ball across a certain arc on aforementioned trampoline, from above, the golf ball will appear to bend in the presence of the bowling ball. It does NOT interact directly with the bowling ball! It never touches it, and it's not magnetic. The space (fabric of trampoline) is curved, which leads to the apparent altercation in course of the golf ball.

5. Real scientists do not say, "I don't give a crap who tries to stop me."
In fact, I am furious that you would insult the majesty of science with this closed-minded lunatic ranting. Go to school, read a book or two, and then, only then, talk with authority. If you don't know the first god damn thing you are talking about (which is clearly the case), don't talk with authority. Instead, you might say, "this theory seems compelling to me, help me understand what might be right or wrong about it."

6. This is not a theory. A theory must predict the outcome of experiment. This is a superstitious belief that is not at all well thought out, and has no impact on science.

Seriously, go read a book. Jesus.


Back | Reverse |

Copyright 2000-2024 Gendou | Terms of Use | Page loaded in 0.0021 seconds at 2024-05-11 04:53:30