|
Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
|
I actually watched both manga and anime of Midori no Hibi (midori days), and I think both were great! But I prefer manga better since there are a lot of things that the midori ni hibi manga has than in anime...but there are also some in anime that cannot be seen in the manga. Usually, the manga is just short but very fantastic (eh, and there's a bit of nudity X_X) You can download the manga here, and tell me what do you like better.  |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
| I've seen this anime, it is so funny.. I like watching it.. :P |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
| I've seen about half of the anime and read about half of the manga. I like them both even though the anime did leave a lot of stuff out. But up to where I am in the anime, it doesn't seem like anything they left out was anything important. |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
|
there IS one episode that they left out from the manga, the part where Seiji gets to dress up like a girl (haven't saw that in the anime, neh?) O_O;; |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
|
o ive always wanted to watch this anime! i want! well, i think anime is better for me cos i love animation and it moves! although maybe the stories in mangas are much more explainatory and has more elements, the anime i think should have enuff substance to keep the story plot moving. so i think anime is better, but this is w/o comparing the elements in story
black cat
|
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
Link |
by
on 2006-09-02 07:09:56 |
both i love smanga and watch anime so i like both of them  --> |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
| I love the anime...it's soooo hilarious...I like the scenes where Midori was picking out clothes for herself at the otaku store...hehehe...sooo cute...I haven't read all the manga...so I can't be too sure in which one is better... |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
Link |
by
on 2006-09-03 20:42:46 |
Prefered manga... more stuff compared to that anime... sure is that the anime looks to me like a rush job.  |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
| Dont know about the manga but i loved the anime and it actualy made me cry in the end ^^; |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
Link |
by
on 2006-09-04 08:03:25 |
The anime ending left me with a rather "blah" feeling. I was expecting it to be more romantic. I got more of a friendly vibe between Seiji and Midori. Gah, I think the manga might be better.  |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
| Manga. It's funnier. |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
|
A lot more stuff happens in the manga... Specially concerning side-characters like Kouta, in the anime they seem to "forget" he has a crush on Seiji (the chapter when he dresses like a girl is hilarious XD), the Makinohas don't even exist (okay, they're pretty much useless to the story, but I lve Nao =p) and Lucy doesn't show up (I like her T__T). I think the anime is pretty good as a light comedy, but the manga is a lot better.
"From East Middle School, Suzumiya Haruhi.
I'm have no interest in ordinary humans. If there are any aliens, time travelers, sliders or espers here, then come join me."
|
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
|
manga midori no hibi is quite intresting at first buti think i got boring after chapter 20 and so on. maybe because i've already watch the anime version which end at 13 series, and the story does not seem to attract me anymore. i love the anime much better |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
|
Well, the anime ending was pretty sad, but the second to last chapter in the manga was such a tear jerker. I don't think that if you read the whole thing, it would be impossible not to cry.
Whoa
|
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
Link |
by blueanime27
on 2008-02-08 23:47:08 |
I haven't read the manga yet so..i'll read it first and i'll tell u den.. but i really like watching this anime!    
-what is found here might be found elsewhere but something not found in here may also not be found anywhere- |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
Link |
by
on 2008-02-09 08:20:09 |
|
I watched its anime...It was great!One of my favorites XD But like some said,it's missing most of the part only manga have.I'll read its manga one day. |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
|
The manga's waaaay better than the anime. Besides character development, the sheer funniness of the manga remains unbeaten. I mean, characters like Kouta, Nao, Takamizawa etc. don't look almost as good in the anime as in the manga. Plus, I'm still drooling over Ayase and Yukari in the colored title page of Ch.22 XD.  --> |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
Link |
by
on 2008-02-10 01:14:56 |
|
I prefer manga. It's more complete. |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
Link |
by
 
on 2008-02-16 17:37:03 |
|
i'm not sure.. i've only read the manga. |
|
Re: Midori no hibi: Manga or Anime?
Link |
by
 
on 2008-02-16 20:25:17 |
|
Manga and Anime ish almost teh same... "take note of ALWAYS"... but I liked teh art on teh anime more than I liked teh art on teh manga... XP, really love their voices... they suit them... HK's choice: Anime 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
Go to page: 0,
1 Displaying 1 to 20 of 24 Entries.