|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
|
| We're all anxious to know the results *eats nails and fingers* |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
 
on 2009-11-18 18:16:21 |
|
Aaaaah the links have been fixed!! Thank you Charlotte for letting me know *huuuuuuuuuugs AND FINALLY THE RESULTS! KONA VS. SHIOYEE --WINNER: SHIOYEE Judge Jose: Comments: This was a tough one. Kona features a wonderful, memorable video, a smooth voice, and a soulful interpretation. But Shioyee - despite her occasional lapses - takes chances, resulting in an enjoyable song, whose delicate interpretation is accented by her incredible resonance and richness of tone Winner: SHIOYEE Judge Pame Comment: Both have nice voices, very different singing style. Both chose ballads which made it harder to pick one of you, but I feel Shioyee had a more professional sound compared to Kona. WINNER: SHIOYEE Judge Eve Comment: Shioyee sang very well. The song fits your voice, you chose well WINNER: SHIOYEE Judge Bubsterella Her interpretaion and technique were the vehicles through which she conveyed the full richness of the song, rather than touching on the potential that the song could offer. Harmonies were superior, and added to rather than distracted from her performance. I was moved WINNER: SHIOYEE Judge Josh I like the quality of the production that she put forth. She's very clean, emotional and clear. I think that Shioyee did a beautiful job but Kona simply put something forth that's simply more professional. WINNER: KONA Judge Traci both were really good WINNER: SHIOYEE Judge Benny Tough call. But Shioyee has more maturity in her voice than Kona. WINNER: SHIOYEE Judge Charllotee WINNER: KONA EERIECHAN VS. RYOKO WINNER: EERIECHAN Judge Pame Ryoko vs. Eeriechan Winner: Eeriechan Ryoko, you have a very nice voice but I think the song was too low for your range and Eeriechan completely took over with the song she picked. Good job. Judge Eve Ryoko vs. Eeriechan Winner: Eeriechan Eeriechan, I fell in love with you as soon as you hit the first note. The song fits you perfectly, not only for your range, but also your style. Judge Benny Winner: Eeriechan Pretty song, pretty voice. Judge Bubsterella Winner: Eeriechan Haunting. More professional quality to her voice. There is more energy and feeling than Ryoko. Judge Charlotte Winner: Ryoko Judge Jose Winner: Eeriechan Comments: Ryoko is a solid contender, whose interpretation and excellent tone-bending make for an enjoyable song. Eeriechan, however, has excellent control and a gorgeous voice, along with excellent production values. Judge Josh Eeriechan ~ I love the energy that comes from Eeriechan's piece and the quality of her tone. She gives me a nastalgic feeling when she sings. I feel that Ryoko, although a skilled singer, sings from her throat a bit too much. It produces a tone that can be harsh at times Judge Traci Winner: Eeriechan -loved the feeling in the song! SHIKAMACHU VS. LUIGI -AAARRRG IT IS A TIE! Judge Jose Winner: Luigi Comments: Shikamachi has a lovely voice, as well as wonderful control - especially in the lower registers. Luigi's interpretation, however, is energetic and refreshing, as is his excellent vibrato. Judge Josh Winner:Shikamachu ~ This is another case of a very polished and professional piece. Luigi has a great voice and tons of energy, but Shikamachu's overall performance makes me want to dance and it isn't even a fast song... I guess it makes me want to slow dance... Judge Benny Winner: Luigi I had a hard time with this one. Judge Traci Winner:Luigi It was hard to choose! Both great voices! Judge Eve Winner:Luigi I really thought I was listening to the original when Luigi was singing. I was very impressed with your singing, nice job. Judge Charlotte Winner: Shikamachu - I have to tell you that this was the hardest decision I've ever made in my life. I loved both of them so much! Judge Pame Winner: Shikamachu I had a very hard time...A VERY HARD time with this one! I absolutely love Luigi's voice he puts a lot of emotion and he gave me the chills, but on the other side Shikamachu simply nails her singing technique. Her notes are perfect and she also had emotion on her voice. If I could make it a tie, I would have done it. Judge Busterella Winner: Shikamachu. Hard choice. Luigi, your heart is magnificent, though you lacked the control that Shikamachu had in spades. When stuck between interpretation and technique, I've given it to technique. I know how hard a skill it can be to master one's vocal control! LUCY VS MIKY Judge Bubsterella Winner:Miky Hardest choice!When it comes down to pure goosebumps, I'll have to give it to Miky. Both had outstanding technique and powerful harmonies, but Miky produced somehow something not unlike lightning in a bottle. Judge Benny Winner: Miky Miky has more presence. Judge Pame Winner: Miky Again I had a very hard time with the judging!! You both drove me crazy. I adore both of your voices. Lucy, your harmonies were beatiful as always, but Miky, you gave me goosepumps. Judge Eve Winner: Lucy I picked Lucy because she maintained her intonation throughout the whole song, but Miky had little mistakes here and there. Judge Charlotte Winner: LUCY Judge Josh Winner: Lucy ~ Lucy vs. Miky was a tough pick for me. They very have a great deal of control and lovely voices. When it comes down to it, it's Lucy's employment of subtle trills and smooth switching from her natural voice to her head voice that really gets me and my pick. Judge Jose Winner: Lucy Comments: This one was so hard! Both contestants are among my favorite entrants ever. Miky's singing is wonderful to listen to, due to her masterful use of vocal effects, excellent emotion, and lovely vibrato. Lucy, however, has a wonderfully delicate, almost airy quality about her voice; her rich harmonies are beautiful, and her interpretation is genuine and perfectly suited to the song at hand. Judge Traci COMING SOON... ENGEL VS. RUBYSAKURA COMING SOON HITOMI VS RENNETTE COMING SOON PEGAOSKA VS. NAZ COMIIING SOON PLEASE FIRST I WANT TO KNOW YOUR OPINION...SHOULD LUIGI AND SHIKAMACHU BE BOTH MOVE OR SHOULD WE VOTE FOR ONLY ONE OF THEM? THANKS! |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-18 18:55:05 |
| I think that both Luigi and Shikamachu should be allowed to move on. I feel that if the judges really had such a difficult time picking between the two and it was a tie, that there is a reason for this and that they should both be awarded for their hard work. |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
|
| O.O, well, let's think, just as there was a tie between Luigi and Shikamachu, it looks like it may be a tie between Lucy and Miky too (we don't know yet,'cause there's a judge decision awaiting), so it really depends on how many ties there are gonna be to decide, I think, if they all go through the next round or let votes decide. |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-18 23:07:11 |
|
I'm probably shooting myself in the foot, AND SO GLAD I wasn't a judge, but this is a "DEATH MATCH", right? People should get hacked off mercilessly. That's the point of this particular contest? >D So I'm one for "no tie". It's no fun if you don't see the best fall to each other. >.> Plus, it gives people like me a chance, lol. |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-19 11:50:54 (edited 2009-11-19 11:54:47)
|
|
oh..i am not late to see Engelz's singing right?!?! i wish i am not!! i am looking forward !! OH OH! and about them both of them should MOVE and have another battle again!!! i think it would be fair enough since they both have a tie and they should deserve a second chance to move on the next battle [edit] oh,i have a better idea! let them have a rematch,but this time RESTRICTED to a specific genre of the songs or maybe give them a fixed song and try to find out who can move on to the next battle ;o it is just an idea though ;x |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-19 14:32:08 (edited 2009-11-19 14:33:33)
|
|
OK JUDGES WILL DECIDE AGAIN WHICH PERSON MOVES LUIGI OR SHIKAMACHU JUDGE TRACI LUCY VS MIKY WINNER: LUCY While I loved both, Lucy had more control of her voice and seemed to sing with more skill. I actually preferred Milky's style and song but I think Lucy deserves the win in this match. (-: Both are awesome though!) ENGEL VS. RUBYSAKURA WINNER: RUBYSAKURA JUDGE PAME Winner: Rubysakura I like Engel's style of singing but Rubysakura had a stronger presence with her singing. Both had some mistakes with the intonation, so be careful. JUDGE BENNY Winner: Engel Both were shaky but one was less so. JUDGE CHARLOTTE Winner: RubySakura JUDGE EVE Winner: Rubysakura Rubysakura showed off better than Engel with her song selection. Rubysakura has good technique, but check your intonation a bit. JUDGE JOSE Winner: Engel Comments: Engel has a smooth voice, and a wonderful interpretation. Rubysakura, however, is highly energetic and wonderful to hear, especially on the higher notes. JUDGE TRACI Winner:Rubysakura Hard to choose! JUDGE JOSH Winner: Rubysakura ~ Ruby and Engel was a tough pick for me as well. I couldn't decide upon a winner by weighing their strengths, as they add up pretty equally in my head, so I had to pick something that I didn't like. I didn't like the Lalalas in Engel's piece... JUDGE BUSTERELLA Winner: Rubysakura Ladies...both need to improve your intonation. Really. But Rubysakura, I like your style so I have faith in you. HITOMI VS RENNETTE WINNER: HITOMI JUDGE CHARLOTTE Winner: Hitomi JUDGE BENNY Winner: Rennette It was more consistent. JUDGE EVE Winner: Hitomi Hitomi, your overall performance was great, there were some little flaws in the high notes, but still it was impressive. JUDGE TRACI Winner: Hitomi Good job! JUDGE JOSE Winner: Hitomi Comments: Rennette is a solid entry, with good control and a genuine J-Pop sound. Hitomi's interpretation is stunning, however - her voice brings out a complex joy that's wonderful to behold JUDGE JOSH Winner: Hitomi ~ Hitomi's performance is just... Mmm~! I just like it that much. Renette was simply put up against the wrong person 'cause.. .Mmm~! JUDGE PAME Winner: Hitomi Very different styles, but Hitomi's song showed off her voice. JUDGE BUSTERELLA Winner: Hitomi PEGAOSKA VS. NAZ WINNER: NAZ JUDGE PAME Winner: Naz Very hard again...Naz has a softer quality to her voice and Pegajoska has this power in her voice that really gives her a lot of presence. Naz though, I think did more difficult things. JUDGE TRACI Winner: Naz I love that song! Great job! JUDGE JOSE Winner: Naz Comments: Pegajoska's gorgeous tone and excellent power make her song truly stand out. On the other hand, Naz's cover is lovely, addictive, and stands solidly on par with the original. JUDGE BUBSTERELLA Winner: Pegajoska Comments: Both did great. Pegajoska gave me the chills. JUDGE EVE Winner: Pegajoska First of all, I am a huge Nana fan, so Pegajoska singing this song made me smile but, since I am a fan I was going to be extra picky. You succedeed though. Good job. JUDGE CHARLOTTE WINNER: Naz JUDGE JOSH WINNER: Naz ~ Naz is another one who is just tough to compete with. Pegajoska did a wonderful job. But Naz's performance just takes me away. I think I end up leaving my breath behind in the process.. JUDGE BENNY Winner: Pegajoska She has a fuller voice even over the guitar. THANK YOU TO ALL OF YOU WHO PARTICIPATED...THIS WAS TRULY A DEATH MATCH: LUIGI AND SHIKAMACHU ARE BEING RE EVALUATED BY THE JUDGES. SO FAR: SHIOYEE, EERIECHAN, LUCY, RUBYSAKURA, HITOMI, NAZ. YOU ARE MOVING INTO THE 2ND STAGE OF THE DEATH MATCH. PLEASE...START DECIDING WHICH JUDGE IS YOUR FAVORITE ^-^ AND I WILL LET YOU KNOW WHEN TO LET ME KNOW. AND HAVE A SONG READY ALSO...PLEASE VOTE FOR ONLY ONE OF THE FOLLOWING: KONA RYOKO MIKY ENGEL RENNETTE PEGAJOSKA THANKS |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
|
| Wouldn't be better if votes come after we know what the judges decide about Luigi or Shikamachu? Just so the one that doesn't go through will have the same chance to be voted for. |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-19 17:04:17 |
| I vote for Kona! Go Kona-chan, go! Your voice is absolutely gorgeous, and I know that you can do a great job. |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
|
|
I will wait until I know the results of Luigi vs. Shikamachu... I think it will be fair to wait for all... Regards!!! ^-^  |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
|
|
My vote is for pegajoska, I really like her voice and how she manages to get the perfect tone in her interpretation. Her tone is unique and her style is lovely.
Syao loves Ed
|
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-20 00:20:28 |
| I realized after I voted that if Shikamachu and Luigi have to go up against one another again, I'll have more people to choose from to vote for. Can I withdraw my vote until this is all settled? |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
 
on 2009-11-20 06:24:03 |
|
I am currently having a heart attack. But in a good way. This is fun XD ~ <33333  ✮ ✩ Check out my ✮ Muscles! ✩ ....✩ I mean, YouTube! ✮ ✩ ★ |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
 
on 2009-11-20 07:08:52 |
|
Actually... I didn't like the Lalalas too much neither... hahah!! But I couldn't sing when I was informed of the competition so had no choice but to bring out an old piece... Enough of ~my excuses... Congrats to all those going to the next round~~ >.<  |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-20 08:28:12 (edited 2009-11-20 08:49:26)
|
|
YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT PEOPLE... I APOLOGIZE FOR THE LITTLE MISTAKE. OKIES...SHIKAMACHU HAS WON THE CHALLENGE. LET ME TELL YOU IT WAS VERY CLOSE, SOME JUDGES CHANGED THEIR MINDS AND ALL. IT WAS INDEED A VERY HARD CHOICE. LUIGI YOU DID WONDERFULLY THOUGH AND A LOT OF JUDGES SUPPORT MY VIEW :) oooh i FORGOT TO SAY: FINALISTS...PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU HAVE A SONG READY :) AND START THINKING ABOUT YOUR FAVORITE JUDGE...YOU MUST PICK ONE SOON :) PLEASE VOTE FOR ONE OF THE FOLLOWING: KONA RYOKO LUIGI MIKY ENGEL RENNETTE PEGAJOSKA THANK YOU! |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by lucyblossom
on 2009-11-20 09:40:06 (edited 2009-11-20 09:49:01)
|
|
OMG!!! that was certainly a death match x___x Everyone did great and I wish I could vote for.... wait! o.o contestants are allowed to vote?? I supposed we are cuz we were allowed the last season of GI, but if we're not... please only ignore my comment n.nU However, If i could i would vote for Pegajoska or Miky because they were absolutely awesome, but! seeing last results my vote is for LUIGI!!! *-* he definitely must move to next stage! I almost forgot... Pame chan o.o our next song has to be a new one? or could be something we used like an entry at GI contest? |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-20 09:56:06 |
|
LUCY: You can pick anything you have used previously in another season or a new song ^-^ OKIES PEOPLE KEEP VOTING PLEASE... FINALISTS...PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU HAVE A SONG AND START THINKING OF YOUR FAVORITE JUDGE SO YOU CAN PICK ONE. |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
|
| Ok, then, I'm voting for Luigi, he was too close, so he has to move on >_< |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
Link |
by
on 2009-11-20 12:43:26 |
|
My gosh, really, this is a hard competition *faints* Gotta vote for Luigi then ( if I can vote of course) I want to have him on the game~ he's just so awesome and he deserves it =D |
|
Re: GENDOU IDOL DEATH MATCH- ROUND 2 STARTED!
|
|
My vote is for Luigi he was very close so he deserve good look to everyone!
music its my live
|